What a clearness committee is for
Friends have long turned to a clearness committee as part of membership and marriage. More recently, a Friend may ask for one to help discern how best to approach an important personal decision, whether to make a change in the circumstances of their life, whether to test a leading, or for another reason.
A Friend usually makes the request to the Meeting’s ministry and care committee, and may suggest people they would like to have on the committee.
The heart of it: the committee does not give advice and does not tell stories of its own similar experiences. Its members ask questions that help the Friend discern whether there is enough clarity to move forward.
What usually happens at the first meeting
- Worship at the beginning and the end, and perhaps at other moments along the way.
- Deep listening to the Friend’s opening statement about the leading, issue or decision.
- Open-ended, probing questions from the committee, carefully formed, to help the Friend see the concern more clearly and what different choices might mean for the Friend, family, the Meeting and perhaps the wider community.
- Time for the Friend to respond, and for everyone to ask together whether more questions need exploring.
- Next steps: perhaps more meetings, or more exploration of the parts that are not yet clear or not yet ready for a decision.
Confidentiality and what comes after
What the Friend writes beforehand and shares in the session is confidential, and both the Friend and the committee members are expected to honor that. Even so, the committee that formed the clearness committee usually receives a report, without details.
If the Friend and the committee come to unity on seeking the Meeting’s support for a leading, the matter goes to the ministry and care committee and then to meeting for business. If the Meeting decides to support it, the clerk may draft a minute of support, and the Meeting may also name a committee to offer guidance, support and accountability.
A word about this guide
This is a thinking aid, not a rulebook. Your own Meeting’s practice comes first, and it may differ in some details from what is described here. If a situation involves someone’s safety, please turn to your Meeting’s ministry and care committee, or to appropriate professional help, rather than a clearness committee alone.
Your short paper
Friends are encouraged to write a brief account of the issue or leading before the first meeting, with the background and any steps that might be taken. The committee reads and reflects on it ahead of time.
Nothing you type here is saved or sent anywhere. It stays on this screen and disappears when you close the page, so please copy or print your paper before you leave.
Your paper, as it will read
Before you meet
- Share your paper with the committee in advance, as the Meeting arranges.
- Expect questions, not advice. You are not asked to defend your thinking.
- You may find it helpful to bring the paper and a pen. The committee will hold what you share in confidence.
Your role
Your part is to ask questions, not to advise. Please also set aside the stories of your own similar experiences, however well meant. The aim is to help the Friend discern whether there is enough clarity to move forward, and to help them see what each choice might mean for them and for others.
Before the first meeting, read and reflect on the Friend’s paper. During it, expect worship at the beginning and the end, deep listening to the Friend’s opening statement, then questions that are carefully formed and open-ended.
Sample questions
These are examples written for this guide, not taken from Faith and Practice. They are here to spark your own. The best questions usually come from listening.
When a leading may need the Meeting’s support
If the Friend’s concern is a leading that might call for the Meeting’s help or formal recognition, you may want a few more questions in mind. Illinois Yearly Meeting’s Faith and Practice offers a thoughtful set. Its questions touch on:
- the nature of the leading, and the gifts needed to follow it
- whether this is the right time, and what is still unclear
- the challenges ahead, and how the Meeting might help with them
- whether formal recognition would help the leading along
- how following it may affect the Friend’s spiritual journey, the Meeting’s life, and the Friend’s other responsibilities
- the spiritual and practical support the Friend will need, and how much of it to look for from the Meeting
Read Illinois Yearly Meeting’s questions in full (section on Recognition of Leadings, in “Recognizing Spiritual Gifts and Leadings”).
When advice sneaks in
It is easy for advice or a story to slip into a question. Here are a few common ones, and a more open way to ask. These are examples to adapt.
| Instead of… | Try… |
|---|---|
| “Don’t you think you should wait until spring?” (advice) | “What does the timing feel like to you?” |
| “When I faced something like this, I…” (your own story) | Hold the story, and ask: “What is hardest about this for you?” |
| “Are you sure this is really a leading?” (a challenge) | “What makes this feel like a leading to you?” |
| “Have you tried talking to a counselor?” (fixing) | “What kind of support would help you most right now?” |
Afterward
- Keep in confidence what the Friend wrote and shared.
- Expect to give the ministry and care committee a report without details.
- If the Friend and the committee are in unity to seek the Meeting’s support, the matter goes to that committee and then to meeting for business. The clerk may then draft a minute of support, and a committee may be named to offer guidance, support and accountability.